The Magpies' European campaign started with so much promise, and they only have themselves to blame for finishing bottom of the 'Group of Death'

Newcastle marked their first home game in the Champions League since 2003 in some style, thrashing Paris Saint-Germain 4-1 in front of a rocking St James' Park crowd. It was a result that sent shockwaves through the entire footballing world, and one that ensured Eddie Howe's side sat top of Group F with four points after two matches.

That fateful October night should have been the start of something special. The Magpies returned to Europe's flagship competition after a 20-year absence on the back of a hard-earned fourth place Premier League finish in 2022-23, only to be cruelly drawn against PSG, AC Milan and Borussia Dortmund.

After overpowering the French champions in such impressive fashion, for an all-too brief moment, Newcastle looked like they could defy all the odds by winning the so-called 'Group of Death'. PSG have underachieved in the Champions League for many years, but very few teams have blown them away, or indeed managed to keep Kylian Mbappe quiet.

From that position, Newcastle really should have qualified for the last-16, or at the very least secured a third-place spot that would have seen them playing Europa League football in the new year. Alas, by the end of their last group game against Milan, their continental dream was up in smoke, with second-half goals from Christian Pulisic and Samuel Chukwueze giving the Italian giants a 2-1 victory on Tyneside.

The question is: how did it all go so wrong? Well, there is no doubt that bad luck played a role, with controversial VAR decisions and an unprecedented injury crisis forcing Howe to rip up his usual playbook.

But the reality is, Newcastle only have themselves to blame for a disastrous end to their European campaign, and more misery will be on the cards unless Howe takes drastic measures to address their alarming recent decline…

GettyMissed opportunity

"It's not beyond our wildest dreams because we did have some wild dreams." The famous words of the late Sir Bobby Robson were displayed on a huge banner for the whole Newcastle squad to see in the Gallowsgate End just before kick-off against Milan on Wednesday night, which combined with the iconic Champions League anthem, provided the players with an injection of pure motivation.

They rose to the occasion initially, with Joelinton's 33rd minute thunderbolt deservedly giving Newcastle the lead and putting them in the driving seat for the runners' up spot in the group. There was another huge roar from the crowd early in the second-half, too, as news filtered through of Karim Adeyemi's opener for Borussia Dortmund against PSG at Signal Iduna Park.

PSG swiftly got themselves level via a goal from 17-year-old sensation Warren Zaïre-Emery, but at that stage, Newcastle just had to stay calm and protect their advantage. They'd done a good job of holding off Milan and the general mood in the stands at St James' Park was still one of optimism.

But only a few minutes later, Milan were level, with USMNT star Christian Pulisic turning a clever pass from Oliver Giroud into the net from close range. Newcastle allowed Rafael Leao to get in behind on the left-flank for the initial cross into the box far too easily, and their static defence was duly punished.

That goal changed the entire dynamic of the night for Newcastle, who then had no choice but to get on the front-foot and go all-out for the crucial winning goal that would give them fresh hope of qualification for the last-16. They had their moments, with Bruno Guimaraes coming agonisingly close to scoring with a fine curling effort from outside the box that was tipped onto the bar by Milan goalkeeper Mike Maignan, but the Serie A side always looked ready to hit again on the counter.

Newcastle survived one scare as Leao struck the post after being played through on-one-one with Martin Dubravka, but with just seven minutes remaining, Milan got their inevitable second goal. The Rossoneri turned defence to attack in the blink of an eye once again, and this time Chukwueze provided the finish, brilliantly placing a first time-shot into the far corner.

AdvertisementGetty'Small margins'

"The save at 1-1, how close it is to going in, they are small margins," Howe said in a defiant tone at his post-match press conference. "I don't think we have been outplayed in any game — the Dortmund game could have been different, but that's the elite element of the game at this level.

"I feel for the players. I have seen what they've given. We weren't at our absolute best tonight. It's painful for me and them because I know how much they have put in."

Newcastle certainly weren't "outplayed" in their third group game against Dortmund, hitting the woodwork twice in the dying minutes before falling to a shock 1-0 defeat, but the visitors were more streetwise. The same was true for the return fixture in Germany, which saw BVB run out 2-0 winners thanks to goals from Niclas Fullkrug and Julian Brandt.

Howe's men bounced back from those losses with a battling performance against PSG at the Parc des Princes, which saw Mbappe break their hearts with a 98th minute equaliser from the penalty spot after Tino Livramento was harshly penalised for handball. To have three points snatched away in such controversial fashion was a bitter pill to swallow for the Magpies, but in truth, the 1-1 draw was the least PSG deserved after boasting 72 percent possession and 31 shots.

Newcastle also played with their backs against the wall on matchday one as they held Milan to a 0-0 stalemate, after perhaps giving their opponents a bit too much respect. That lack of bravery going forward in away fixtures ultimately proved costly.

The only time Howe really let his team off the leash for a full 90 minutes was in the 4-1 demolition of PSG on their own soil, and he must take a large portion of blame for reverting to a safety-first approach in subsequent matches. Newcastle should never have been going into their final game relying on a result from elsewhere, with Milan eventually able to pick them off when desperation set in.

Getty ImagesChampions League rookies

The manner of Newcastle's loss to Milan was excruciating, but the final result was not a surprise to anyone that watched their last two Premier League games. Heavy defeats at Everton and Tottenham have left the Magpies languishing down in seventh in the table, seven points behind fourth-placed Manchester City, and Howe has a huge task on his hands to plug the gaps at the back.

He has not been helped by a mounting injury list, to which Kieran Trippier and Anthony Gordon were added in midweek. Eight senior players missed what turned out to be Newcastle's final Champions League game, with Nick Pope, Joe Willock, Matt Targett, Jacob Murphy, and Harvey Barnes among those who could be sidelined until the new year.

When quizzed on the situation, Howe told reporters: "We have gone into Champions League games without key players due to injuries and that has hurt us. We've learned so much. The value of the squad, first and foremost, is what has exposed us. The fact we haven't had the ability to utilise the squad we've created… We've gone into games very limited in what we can do, and that hasn't helped us."

The 10-month suspension of club-record signing Sandro Tonali for betting offences was also a huge blow, but Newcastle's European implosion cannot be put down solely to a depleted squad. For the most part, they looked like rookies on the Champions League stage, and opposing teams took advantage of their naivety.

Howe's lack of experience at the very highest level was highlighted, too, with Luis Enrique, Edin Terzic and Stefano Pioli all getting the better of the Englishman in the tactical stakes. Newcastle had their destiny in their own hands after thrashing PSG, but lacked the know-how to finish the job, and it is essential that they learn from what has been a brutal, exhausting experience.

GettyStep up in class

Newcastle did, at least, go down fighting against Milan in search of all three points, as they refused to accept the consolation prize of a Europa League berth after being pulled back to 1-1. For the first time since their home rout of PSG, the Magpies threw caution to the wind and took some risks in the final third, with the Rossoneri somewhat fortunate not to concede another goal or two.

But it was also alarming how wasteful, and at times completely ineffective Newcastle's star attackers were. Callum Wilson led the line with Miguel Almiron and Anthony Gordon providing support on the flanks, but none of them made any meaningful impact on proceedings.

Alexander Isak also struggled after replacing Gordon on the hour mark, with Newcastle's lack of clinical edge ultimately proving to be their undoing in Europe. Indeed, Wilson, Almiron, Gordon and Isak only shared two goals between them during the entire group stage, which suggests that the step up in class from the Premier League to the Champions League was too much.

Wilson and Isak have both scored seven times in the top-fight this season, while Gordon has racked up nine goal contributions to put himself in contention for a place in Gareth Southgate's England squad. Their failure to replicate those numbers in continental competition led to Newcastle posting just six goals in the group stage; only Celtic, Milan and Red Bull Salzburg managed fewer.

Newcastle need more firepower if they are to get back into the Champions League next season and win their first major trophy since 1955, with the Carabao Cup and FA Cup both still up for grabs. However, it remains to be seen whether the club's Saudi-backed owners give Howe another war chest in January, with questions likely to be asked over his position if the Magpies don't finish the year with a run of positive results.